Before the city of Virginia entered into a development agreement with Virginia Hospitality in May 2022, there was already a trove of public records documenting the lengthy business history of the company’s central figure.
The developer, Apurva G. Patel, has for more than two decades proposed site rehabilitations and new hotel builds that span the state of Minnesota with varying success. Virginia officials added to that history in 2021 by selecting him for its planned hotel adjacent to the Iron Trail Motors Event Center, a key piece for one of the city’s most ambitious projects to date.
An Iron Range Today investigation reviewed hundreds of pages of court filings, mortgage documents, property records and city contracts tracing Patel’s development history in Minnesota and Virginia’s handling of the hotel.
Those records show repeated litigation over contracts, payments, bankruptcies and foreclosures around Patel, while also illuminating the city’s oversight on a project that long exceeded all of its timelines.
As Iron Range Today reviewed the agreements between Patel and Virginia, questions about the city’s legal remedies emerged should the project not be completed, and prompted officials to acknowledge they initially cited an unsigned agreement about a critical piece of the overall hotel deal.
There are financial implications for the city should Patel default. A 2021 land purchase agreement showed Virginia sold the development property for $1. The lot was valued at $685,000 at the time.
Iron Range Today found no provision in the purchase agreement, development agreement and a 2026 amendment to the development agreement that would automatically revert ownership of the land back to the city if the hotel fails to launch. Virginia officials acknowledged a reversion clause was in the unsigned agreement they previously quoted to Iron Range Today, and then noted a section of it that allows them to pursue available legal remedies if the developer defaults.
“Because we have the potential to be involved in litigation regarding the developer’s alleged failure to perform under the agreement and the First Amendment,” wrote City Administrator Britt See Benes, in an email to Iron Range Today on Monday, “I cannot comment further on the available remedies or the City’s legal strategy at this time.”
More than five years since Virginia moved ahead with Patel, the only visible progress is a chainlink fence erected in late June around the empty lot. Nearly a month later, no equipment or crews have returned to the site for a meaningful period.
This report from Iron Range Today is a product of weeks of investigation and follows Patel’s path through Minnesota, reconstructed through public records. It also tracks the city’s dealings with Patel and public updates delivered through the years.
Virginia officials said the selection of a developer followed the standard request for proposals process, and that the city remained confident in the hotel. Last Tuesday night, the Virginia City Council entered a closed session about the project and took no action.
“It is my understanding sufficient review of the developer, projects and financials was conducted by city staff and Council, as well as a site tour of similar projects completed by the developer,” wrote Community Development Coordinator Jenny Bourbonais, in an email late last Friday afternoon.
Patel told Iron Range Today in a phone call last week that hotel development is generally difficult, and a continued trend of high interest rates stalled progress. He acknowledged his past business dealings, and reaffirmed a commitment to the Virginia site.
“I have nothing to hide,” he said. “I could walk away, but that’s not going to be me. I’ve got a million-four into this damn thing … I’m the only game in town willing to lose another $3 million.”
****
Patel said he moved with his parents from India to the United States at the age of 7. He’s now 62 and spoke often of giving back to the country that provided his family with opportunities.
The earliest public record of Patel’s business dealings date back to June 2004, when Best Western filed a trademark infringement lawsuit against him and the Minnesota-based Kashi Corp. A judge in February 2005, after Patel and Kashi representatives were no-shows to numerous proceedings, issued a default judgement in favor of Best Western for approximately $249,000.
About a year after the judgement, Patel submitted photos of the site in question — the former Best Western on the University of Minnesota campus that was by then demolished — and the judge opted against holding them in contempt. The financial penalty stood.
In 2009, a company called Duluth Management filed for bankruptcy with Patel among its leadership. Records show Duluth Management led a hotel in Monticello and a liquor store in Rosemount.
Years later in 2013, a director of Duluth Management sued Patel and a business partner, accusing them of mishandling funds and improperly reshaping the board. Asvin Patel said he invested $100,000 into Virginia Enterprises in 2008, but accused Apurva Patel and his business partner of using it for “their own personal purposes and then lost or squandered the funds.”
The suit was settled almost a year later.
Patel and his wife, Sarika, filed for personal bankruptcy in 2014, citing business debt and more than $797,000 in federal and Minnesota back taxes. The filing showed $60,000 owed to Asvin Patel, as well as the Best Western award. In its totality, the bankruptcy filing linked Patel to a number of other court proceedings when crosschecked with listed addresses and associates.
Among them was another default judgement in 2005 that stemmed from a lawsuit alleging Patel and Tombstone Hospitality ended a licensing agreement with Choice Hotels International, but that he continued to use the company’s Quality Inn logo and name in St. Cloud. Again, neither Patel nor a Tombstone representative appeared in the case. The $88,000 award for Choice was paid by 2007.
At least three other contract lawsuits were filed against him and various companies in Minnesota courts between 2004 and 2014.
“Development is development,” Patel said. “I lost $6 million in 2008 when the economy went to hell in a handbasket. It was shitty as all hell, but we did it. I basically came out of it and paid off whoever I needed to.”
Patel’s timeline in Minnesota appears to phase out after the 2014 bankruptcy. Calling himself a “serial entrepreneur,” he said he leaned on his background as an architect and did work in New Jersey, California and other states. He re-emerged in Minnesota public documents in 2019, connected to a downtown Duluth property.
Two years later, he came into the Iron Range picture.
Virginia pitched the redevelopment of the former Miners Memorial complex hard to its residents. The city secured state funds and legislative approval on a 1% sales tax for the event center. It just needed the votes.
This was not a slam dunk ballot measure. Voters had rejected an effort to renovate the Miners, but a redevelopment plan arrived in front of them shortly after the Rock Ridge consolidation cleared the way for new school buildings. The Range had an appetite for new construction, and the valued-added hotel represented something more than a new hockey arena.
But the current stalled status of the hotel comes as the city faces a serious financial situation, the misplacement of $3.7 million of sales tax funds generated for the event center, high long-term debt and an increasingly complex budget for a small-city staff.
****
Patel and Virginia Hospitality were selected by the city in 2021, and a plan on how to guide the hotel through the levers of city government came together.
In August of that year, according to city meeting minutes, Patel would tell a special meeting of the Virginia City Council that a proposed prototype of the hotel was approved as a Marriott franchise. It would have underground parking, a rooftop deck and more bells and whistles than any other hotel in the Quad Cities area.
Representatives for Marriott were left numerous emails and messages by Iron Range Today to confirm the chain’s work with Patel. They did not respond.
The city approved a tax-increment finance (TIF) district in 2021 spread over several years, and in turn conveyed the vacant land to Virginia Hospitality and Patel. The original development agreement was signed in May 2022.
According to that agreement, construction was set to begin on July 1, 2022, provided there were no “unavoidable delays” and completed by December 2023.
Patel blamed the lack of construction on interest rates nearly doubling from in late 2022 to 7.5% and peaking to 8.5% between 2023 and 2024. Federal Reserve data shows interest rates climbed in those years, but have lowered to a post-peak rate of below 7%, yet far-above the 3.5% rate in early 2022.
“If I can build it, and it was viable and I had everything lined up … the rug fell off when we started seeing interest rates at 8-9%,” he said. “It’s hard to do hotels in this world. I went to 40 banks when I started and got 40 denials.”
City and county documents seem to back his struggle on securing funds, to an extent, and suggest informal conversations were occurring on the status.
Patel purchased the old armory site from a local couple for $325,000 in May 2023 — about 85% higher than the land’s assessed value ($176,400) — through another company called Development Services Group.
Despite being 13 months past the original timeline to start construction, on Aug. 1, 2023, Virginia officials approved a subordinate agreement to the TIF. It allowed Patel to pledge his rights to future TIF reimbursements to Frandsen Bank as loan collateral, while preserving the original development agreement.
During that meeting, Patel told the committee of the whole that modular units were ordered and would be built in 2024. He predicted the hotel would open in December 2024 or January 2025. He referenced interest rates and material costs in contributing to the delays.
“You’ll see a three-story rise up in two or three weeks next August,” Patel said. “Contracts are signed. The machinery should be here fairly quickly.”
The committee of councilors expressed optimism and asked no questions, but Mayor Larry Cuffe Jr. and Councilor Maija Biondich noted to Patel they received a common question from residents: “Is it really going to happen?”
St. Louis County records show that weeks later, on Aug. 30, 2023, a 26-year loan was inked between Virginia Hospitality and Frandsen Bank and Trust for $9.2 million. A second loan was signed that day between Virginia Hospitality and the Northland Foundation for $2 million. They were recorded with the county two weeks later. The city would deed the land to Patel’s company in that same timeframe.
Patel would then go onto work on now-active apartment rehabilitations in Red Wing, while Virginia’s agenda would become largely dominated by the new public safety building construction.
The hotel project went quiet.
Twenty-two months after Patel’s last public meeting appearance, he was back in front of the committee of the whole on June 17, 2025. The hotel land remained as it did in 2023. Cuffe, as the developer walked to the microphone, cautioned residents that specific timelines were still “in the works” for construction.
“Everything is solid,” Patel said, later reinforcing his intent to build. “Just note that I promised a hotel, and it’s been a lengthy while, but I will deliver.”
He outlined what a construction schedule would entail and noted work with Marriott on his desire for an encapsulated outdoor pool. The design didn’t fit the chain’s prototype, he added, suggesting a change in the design from 2021 when Patel reported a concept was accepted by the brand.
Cuffe called the Marriott partnership “a coup” for the city, and praised the developer for still moving along with housing units on the site, which Patel predicted would be phase two of the project starting in early 2026.
The mayor asked Patel how long it would be for the public to see real progress on the hotel site.
“30 days,” Patel said.
****
In February this year, the city of Virginia signed off on an amended development agreement with Patel and Virginia Hospitality.
It would dramatically reduce the expectations for the property and provide more oversight on Patel, requiring his “securing the site, signage, fencing where appropriate” before the new construction start date of June 30.
The scope of the project was reduced from 165,971 square feet and 132 hotel and housing units, to a minimum requirement of 46,000 square feet and a $12 million investment. The agreement called for more timely reports and regular meetings with city staff, and an update on Marriott franchising.
The open-gate fence went up June 29.
Bourbonais, the community development coordinator, confirmed the city was receiving bi-weekly updates from Patel, but no details were provided. She also deferred to Patel for confirmation on the Marriott partnership.
Officials from Red Wing praised the work Patel did in their city’s downtown with two apartment complexes finished and a third project nearly completed. Those officials said details on the projects and the economic impact would be sent for this report, along with a statement supporting him. Patel said he did $18 million of projects in Red Wing, which were easier to complete than hotels as they were multi-family housing.
No information or statement was ultimately delivered to Iron Range Today by the city.
Throughout a roughly 30-minute phone call with Iron Range Today, Patel cited the fencing around the parking lot, that the hotel size was increased to 119 rooms, and said he wants to “revitalize Virginia” with the project. Yet Patel offered no direct reasons for the current delays, despite the $10 million in financing for the city’s hotel, and reiterated he was the only developer who stepped up.
“They need something to be proud of,” he said. “If you can’t get the development correct and stifle development … development needs to spur other development. There’s no local developers. Where are the local rich guys? You know they’re out here.”
About three weeks after the amended agreement was signed in Virginia, Patel was sued by Frandsen Bank over a loan at one of his Duluth buildings, 117 W. Superior St. Under a company called 117 Investments, the bank accused Patel and the business of defaulting on a $634,000 loan for the building.
According to the bank’s claim, 117 Investments had not paid anything on the 2021 loan, which was amended and decreased in 2024. The loan matured in February.
Patel said his relationship with the bank was still amicable, but a new president was recently appointed and refused to renew the loan. Todd Fedora, the president of Frandsen’s Duluth and Hermantown sites, was hired in January.
“I’ve got differences with them,” Patel said. “They are very conservative. Now I have a different source of funding, and now we’re good to go.”
County records showed a satisfied loan to 117 Investments with Citizens Independent Bank in St. Louis Park. Alternate funding sources under 117 Investments were not listed with the county recorder’s office.
Development Services Group, the Patel company that owns the Virginia armory land, has several separate loans for a 31 W. Superior Street building it owns in Duluth. Financing was done through the Minnesota Power Employee Credit Union.
County records also show unpaid property taxes from Patel’s businesses in Duluth and Virginia, some dating back to 2024. Development Services Group owes $25,087 in back taxes on the old armory in Virginia and $47,230 on its property in Duluth. The 117 Investments business is behind $49,244 on its Duluth building, while Virginia Hospitality owes $7,667 on the hotel land.
In all, the businesses owe St. Louis County $129,230.
Patel told Iron Range Today that he wants the Virginia hotel to be his last project. That his goal is to provide for the city and do something for the country his parents immigrated to with him. That his past history “is what it is” at this point.
“You will hear the truth out of me wholeheartedly,” Patel said. “I have nothing to hide. I haven’t hidden anything. I just need to see the city revitalized. If there’s ramifications, it is what it is, it’s a small community. The truth is the truth.”
Artificial intelligence disclosures: AI was used in this story to help research through the hundreds of pages of court documents. All findings used were verified by a real human. Read our AI policy.
